Wish there was more citizen involvement in the Niagara Region

Nine months ago, I and an associate set out on a mission.  We were two residents of  the 80 mile wide Niagara (River) Region.We advocated for travel, tourism, trade and development on both sides of the river in the name of Bi-National Cooperation.  We believe that there is tremendous potential for shared success and growth between the long time, 200 years, peaceful USA and Canadian neighbors along the Niagara River.   We visited business people, tourism people, government people, hotel people, and transportation people.  We met with over forty influential people and groups on both sides of the river.  We attended development and business forums. And in the process, we also found a number of people were not willing to speak with lowly, non-moneyed, non-connected citizens.

Talking with people you find they do want change, want action, want development, want jobs,  want international stature but they want YOU to do it for them.  For every single complaint and followup request to assist us,  you hear ”I don’t have time,”  “I’m not political,” “Nothing will change,” etc.  I personally find this rather disheartening.

Check out the Niagara Region expats in the Sun Belt states, where they hide in their air-conditioned homes throughout their unbearably hot summers or run away up here to escape.  They are more than happy to promote their new abodes to anyone and everyone who will listen while up here on their 4 month summer hiatus from tropical heat.  We, one the other hand,  hide in heated homes during our rarely below 10 degree winter weather travel down south and join in if not even start daily rounds of bashing the community instead of  trying to improve it or promote  our considerable attributes.

I’m not a geneticist or physician, but, there must be some type of genetically developed negativity gene that is embedded in this area.

When we got started, our first thought was -  we shared one of the world’s great geographic and geological treasures.  We also have historic sites, wineries,  Niagara Falls, water activities, culture, architecture, sporting events, and museums to go along with it.  A community effort to promote the area would certainly  make absolute sense to everyone.   It appears we were wrong and our airports tell the story about where you can finds our heads.

The area has two airports, Niagara Falls International  and Buffalo International.  Niagara’s airport has an 11,000ft main runway.  Any aircraft that can fly today has the ability to land there without trouble.  Buffalo’s main runway is smaller at 8800ft.  So it would make sense to  develop long range tourism into Niagara and domestic tourism via Buffalo each feeding the Niagara Region.   What do we end up getting?  Dozens of flights to New York City and Florida taking  American and Canadian locals to those areas while we make no effort to attract them and their tourist dollars to our locale.  That is pretty darn sad when you consider there are people in NYC will to pay upwards of $480 for a ONE DAY day drive by visit to the Falls only – Click here.

I really wonder what the game plan is for the various Chambers of Commerce, Developmental Agencies, Buffalo-Niagara Enterprise, etc.  They don’t target any markets for featured travel packages.  You can’t go online and buy a 3-4-5-6-7 day tour package for the area.  And you won’t see a “Visit US” add anywhere in anyone’s media.  What is the problem?  If your don’t promote, they won’t come.  Advertising works.  The proof is in the pudding.  Just check all the travel packages promotions that you see on television or read in the newspapers for Disney World, Universal Studios, Las Vegas, Texas, etc.

I’ll bet you dollars to donuts that  the residents of those areas speak nothing but praises for their communities because they know if you come, you will spend money, they will have jobs and money (your money), to spend.

There really needs to be a community effort.  If the citizens started putting pressure on their elected officials, they will put pressure on their business associates, and maybe, just maybe, we will see some meaningful development.

 

Germany’s North Rhine-Westphalia State ousts Chancellor Merkel’s party.

Here in the United States, growing numbers of American’s are moving to the Right in support of  Corporate politicsy.  In 2011, here in the Buffalo/Western New York voters cast 65% of the vote for the extreme Right Tea Party whose candidate for governor carried  33 of Erie County’s villages, towns and cities except for the Town of Aurora and City of Buffalo.

Over in Europe, voters appear to have tired of austerity programs that take them to task and not the financial instutitons  that have misbehaved.  The German state of  North Rhine Wesphalia mirrored the recent French presidential elections by handing an election majority victory  to a Socialist-Green Party alliance that will form the new state government.  It was a bad for German  Chancellor Angela Merkel’s conservative Christian Democrats (CDU).  Buffalo’s Sister-City of Dortmund is located in North Rhine Westphalia.

Early regional election results in Germany’s most populous state, North-Rhine Westphalia, show the Social Democrats to be the top party. The party may be set to govern in coalition with the Greens. Voters in the German state of North-Rhine Westphalia gave the Social Democrats (SPD) a clear majority in contrast to 2010, when the Christian Democrats (CDU) eked out a 0.2 percent margin of victory. According to preliminary official figures early on Monday, the SPD won 39.1 percent of the vote – a gain of 4.6 percent. The CDU, Chancellor Angela Merkel’s party and lead partner in the national coalition, took in 26.3 percent, a decrease of 8.3 percent from 2010. This represents the party’s worst result in the state since World War II. Read the whole report.

The City of Bursa, Buffalo NY’s Turkish Sister.

I was not even aware that the City of Buffalo was a Sister-City of Bursa, Turkey.  I am very familiar with it as I have had a life long interest in that region of the world going back to me undergraduate days in college when I studied History and Government.  I centered my studies on the Middle-East, SubSaharan Africa and South Asia.  As the narrator of the video below will tell you, Bursa is a very old center of the Turkish world as capitol of the Ottoman Empire.

Today, Bursa remains one of Turkey’s great cities and Turkey possesses one of the fastest growing national economies in the world and is gaining influence in the world it has not seen in over 100 years. Exactly to kind of place where intelligent local businessmen can participate in this economy both exporting and importing.  It also has a burgeoning middle class that travels and a highly rated national airline, Turkish, which services nearby Pearson International Airport in Toronto, Canada.  We should be inviting Turkish travelers to visit the Niagara Falls region.

And like the residents of the Buffalo area, they love THEIR brand of football and their club - Bursaspor, nicknamed Yeşil İnciler (the Green Pearls),

So if you have a half an hour of free time, watch the attached video on Bursa presented by EbruTV Europa.

YouTube Preview Image

 

 

 

13th Annual Buffalo-Sister Cities Dinner

Last night, at the downtown Buffalo St. Anthony Church Center, a gathering of over 150 individuals, each familiar  with Kanazawa, came together to bread bread and celebrate an international association with the world.  Buffalo, NY is in a proud relationship with 18 cities encompassing the globe:  Kanazawa, Japan;  Lille, France;  Torremagiore, Italy;  St. Ann Parish, Jamaica; Dortmund, Germany;  Siena, Italy;  Rzeszow, Poland;  Bursa, Turkey;  Cape Coat, Ghana;  Drohobych, Ukraine;  Tver, Russia;  Kiryat Gan, Israel; Horlivka, Ukraine;  Abeadze, Ghana;  Chagzhou, China; Bani, Dominican Republic; and, Yeongcheon, Republic of Korea.  Pretty impressive if you ask me and offering a world of opportunity and education.

Coinciding with this year’s annual dinner,  the Buffalo-Kanazawa Japan relationship celebrates its 50th birthday.  Kanazawa is a thriving western Japanese city of 500,000 in a region of over 1 million people.

The evening’s festivities were directed by Rebecca Reilly.  Rebecca is the director of the Yeongcheon Association.  She introduced Emerson Barr, City of Buffalo Liaison to the Associations for a welcome and  opening remarks and then  Louise Simon Schoene who head the New York State Sister Cities Associations.

Those in attendance were then led by Rebecca on a very pleasurable trip through the world of culture which included:  Korean pop music, Jamaican/Caribbean Rhythms, Edith Piaf and French Music, Israeli Folk, African Drumming and Dance, Chinese Dance, Korean and Chinese Martial Arts and a raffle awarding memorabilia from the Sister’s.

At the end, I am sure everyone left pleased with the evening.

I believe  that the efforts of the  various Sister-City Associations  need to be recognized.   The Buffalo-Sister Cities Association has got to be one of the biggest yet least covered civic organizations of its size in all of Western New York.   A good way to begin promoting it could be  a plaque and flag display at the Erie Canal Harbor.

At one time that Erie Canal Terminus was the jump off point for tens of thousands of America’s newly arrived immigrants and additional thousands of citizens enroute to new lives in the West or right here.  Buffalo remains nationally unrecognized as original Gateway to West.  The Federal government never gave us a memorial to commerate the fact.  How nice it would be to visit the harbor and see the flags of the 18 nations that represent the homes of our overseas family flying above our heads proclaiming:   We are part of the world, it is part of us, and all continue to gather here.

 

 

Is Western New York intentionally missing the boat for Tourism?

It is easier to pull a chain than to push one.  The problem with Western New York is that we don’t have anyone pulling the chain.

It started eight months ago on Sept. 15th. 2011 when Attorney Jean Gittler and I met at the Western New York Regional Economic Development Council  forum held at Niagara County Community College to discuss issues of interest to area residents in attendance.  At the forum the main talking points revolved around Tourism and and Agricultural concerns.  Tourism of course because of Niagara Falls, the River, the Gorge, the Casino, and the Historic sites.  Agriculture because benefit the constant talk promoting the notion that this is a blue collar community, we actually have a multibillion dollar agricultural environment centered around, Fruit Orchards, Wineries, Potatoes, Onions, Beef, Dairy and Cheeses.

I had the opportunity to address the group with concerns regarding the poor condition of the local state parks and the fact that there are 8 magnificent hiking trails all along the Niagara River Gorge stretching seven miles from the Rainbow Bridge up to the Artpark State Park in the Village of Lewiston.  Some of the trails have not been adequately maintained since the 1930s.  My belief is that there are millions of hikers around the world who would come to the area to walk these from easy to difficult, trails ans receive a certificate for the effort.

Jean on the other hand spoke of the great number of Canadian visitors who cross the border to shop virtually every day of the year and sell out hotel rooms over the weekends and particularly during holiday seasons.  She wonder why no one has ever attempted to sell out neighbor actual packages with coupons and other enticements to visit the local restaurants, theaters, museums, art galleries, and other cites.  She wondered how can we decide we cannot afford to advertise to attract additional revenues.  After all the television and radio is filled with commercials for Fallsview Casino, Marineland and Game Farm, Niagara Wine Trail, Toronto Weekends, etc.

We spoke afterwards and decided to interject ourselves into the picture as citizens interested in seeing the community along with the Canadian side of the border.  We wanted to find out why it was that with Niagara Falls, the Erie Canal, the Welland Canal, Bi-National Wineries and Wine Trails, three 18th Century European style fortresses, World Class fresh water fishing, Architecture, 3 major amusement parks, professional sports, golfing, and near weekly music-food-arts-ethic festivals we do not market ourselves as a destination.

Since September 15th we have spoken with:

Sam Ferraro, Michael Casale, Susan Langdon, Andrea Klyczek of the Niagara County Center for Economic Development; Kim Minkel, William Vanacek and Pascal Cohen or the NFTA;  Jeffery R. Izzo, Chief of Political and Economic Section, U.S. Consulate General, Toronto, Canada;  Edgar Ramirez, a New York City Based European Tour Operator; Ken Walsh, Commercial Attaché – U.S. Commercial Service – Moscow;  S7 (Formerly Sibir) Airlines Russia;  Emerson Barr and Buffalo Sister-Cities; Buffalo-Dortmund (Germany) -  Drohobych & Horlivka (Ukraine) Sister Cities – Tver (Russia) Sister Cities Groups;  Elizabeth Pelton of the Sheraton at the Falls;  Rep. Kathy Hochul, U.S. Congress;  Dr. Gary Praetzel, Dean Niagara University College of Hospital and Tourism; Renee Simonian of New York State Tourism (not affiliated with New York State Government);  A. Peter Snodgrass, Project Director for Rep. Hochul; Alisa Colatarchi, Chris Sasiadek, Casework for Rep. Hochul;  Chief of Staff to NYS Senator George Maziarz; NYS Senator Mark Grisanti;  Vincent Gaughan, Business Development Eastern Europe-Russia-Central Asia;  Cody Meyers, Deputy Regional Director for Senator Chuck Schumer; Helga Honey, Administrator of the Bi-National Tourism Alliance;   NYS Assemblyman Sean Ryan, Jennifer Ferguson, Direcotr of Marketing for Fallsview Casino;  Len O’Connor, Airport Manager, Niagara District Airport, and various managers for  Days Inn, Hilton Hotel and Suites, Double Tree by Hilton, Sheraton Four Points, Ramada Inn, Embassy Suites,  Sheraton at the Falls, Old Fort Niagara, Freedom Run Winery, and Becker Farms.  A number of big name local leaders would not meet with us.

What we have found is that there is interest but the local chain has too many links making it both impossible to push and extremely difficult to pull.  This area is Balkanized with too many groups being served by too many organizations each acting in their own self-interest and job protection.  As a result people will talk to you on a limited basis but will never give you any follow up.  You can present ideas, but, again there will be no followup.  They will tell you what you want to hear, and then you will never hear from them again.  This is quite disturbing since there is so much public money involved in the development process and it is even more disturbing by the fact that businesses directly involved in travel, tourism, culture, arts and dining don’t care to spend any money on advertising themselves to attract more attention and business.

In my estimation  we have a serious problem on our hands.  We don’t really recognize the potential for the area.  Business people look for reasons for an idea to will fail instead of focusing on how to make something cooperatively succeed.  Niagara Country does not care to cooperate with Erie County and vice-verse, the cities are suspicious of the suburbs and vice versa, the Republicans are suspicious of the Democrats and vice versa, and Americans are suspicious of the Canadians, and vice versa.

We just don’t get it and we must put our petty “protect my turf jealousies” aside for the sake of community health.  India’s Trade Wings Institute, presented this startling discovery and the Bi-National Niagara Region really needs to take heed.

Impact of tourism

As an industry, the impact of tourism is manifold. Tourism industry nourishes a country’s economy, stimulates development process, restores cultural heritage, and helps in maintaining international peace and understanding.

Tourism at present is India’s third largest export industry and the forex earnings is estimated to be about Rs.9186 cores (approx Us $3928 million) in 1995-96.

Employment potential

The most significant feature of the tourism industry is the capacity to generate large scale employment opportunities even in backward areas, specially to women, both educated and uneducated. Another important feature of tourism is that it contributes to national integration of the people who live in different regions of the country with diverse cultures and languages.

Tourism is the greatest!

Tourism, the world’s biggest industry!
What about energy, manufacturing or agriculture?

A survey of 400 policy and opinion makers in 20 countries placed these and three other industries ahead of tourism in global economic contribution, but recently gathered statistics tell a different story.

As a contributor to the global economy, tourism has no equal.

Tourism employs 204 million people worldwide or one in every nine workers, 10.6 percent of the global workforce.
Tourism is the world’s leading economic contributor, producing an incredible 10.2 percent of the world’s gross national product.
Tourism is the leading producer of tax revenues at US$655 billion.
Tourism is the world’s largest industry in terms of gross output approaching US$304 trillion
Tourism accounts for 10.9 percent of all consumer spending, 10.7 percent of all capital investment and 6.9 percent of all government spending

If we don’t take this message to heart and work together instead in the best interest of your little piece of the pie, then we will never grow through participation in one of the world’s great growth markets – TOURISM.

 

Allegiant Air cancels Niagara Falls – Fort Lauderdale route.

The Buffalo News just reported that Allegiant Air will cancel Fort Lauderdale service.  This is not surprising.  Airlines can’t run flights without two way traffic and no apparent effort to grow traffic between two cities.

What does surprise me is the timing.  It was recently that  Attorney Jean Gittler and I  found out about the flight was in trouble.  Just this past Thursday we were out and about meeting with Hotel Managers on both sides of the border attempting to do what no-one  with the Niagara Falls Stakeholders group or Chamber of Commerce cared to do.  We sought their involvement in attracting South Floriday residents to this area.

I guess it is back to the drawing boards.

My condolences to Niagara Falls International Airport management who surely made an effort to get this service off the ground.

 

Flights from Florida to Niagara Falls carry no inbound tourists????

Niagara Falls International Airport is served by two airlines.  Spirit and Allegiant Air.  Combined they offer flights to Myrtle Beach, SC and the Florida cities of  Ft. Lauderdale, Tampa/ St. Petersburg, Orland/ Sanford, Punta Gorda/ Fort Myers (starts 6/29/12).

Travel up to the airport and you see that 90% of the cars have Ontario license plates.  I say good for them that they are able to take advantage of low cost flights out of this facility.  I know that I will be traveling up to Toronto when I am ready to go to London this fall because at the moment YYZ-LON fares are lower.  And that is an advantage of living in a Bi-National area.

The problem as I see it is that the locals don’t understand you cannot support an airline at your airport if the sole business to take people out without attracting travelers at the other end.  No one is coming here and neither the  Niagara Falls business community, nor the County Tourism Office, nor the Chamber of Commerce are making any effort to attract visitors to the area.  Go to the airport and watch when the flights arrive – NO CABS – NO SHUTTLE BUSES – NO CAR RENTALS….

If you speak,  as I have over the past nine months, with local officials and representatives of Niagara County you will hear we need flights  to Florida, flights to Las Vegas and flights to Dublin, Ireland.  No one is saying lets market to anyone to attract tourism.  The effort is totally focused on sending Americans and Canadians elsewhere to spend money without consideration to bring people from the destination areas to Western New York State or the Niagara Peninsula of Ontario.

Do you want some proof?  Visit the Allegiant Air website.  http://www.allegiantair.com/

Click on Flight and Hotel

Click on Departure City and select one of the cities listed above.

Click on Arrival City and select Niagara Falls/Buffalo.

Choose a departure and arrival day.

Hit Search.

You will get this message:

Allegiant Air is proud to partner with many different hotels and resorts in order to offer accommodations in most cities we serve. Unfortunately, we do not offer hotel accommodations in the destination you have chosen.

Amazing isn’t it.  Either not a single hotel in the area wants visitors from Florida, or, the powers that be are not doing their job in letting the business community they need to get into the tourism game big time.

Many days I just shake my head wondering why this area is do determined not to promote itself as a viable destination for people looking for a place to go for a vacation.  We have the Falls, Wineries and Wine Tours in two countries, Casinos and Entertainment in two countries, Historic sites in two countries, three 18th century European fortresses in two countries, theater, dance, clubs, fishing, skiing, swimming, hiking, boat tours, jet boats, professional sports, art galleries, festivals, fairs, outdoor concerts, etc.

If you are a hotel owner or manager.  Get in touch with both Allegiant and Spirit Air.  Tell them you want to be part of their program for attracting riders and in turn your new customers.

Click on the airline:    Spirit AirlinesAllegiant

 

Buffalo, NY needs an overall out with the old and in with the new.

In today’s Buffalo News, Business writer David Robinson had this to say:

It turns out we have the same issues with Canadian shoppers that we do with tourists at Niagara Falls.  They come here, do their thing –be it shopping or look at the falls –and then they leave. That’s it. Not much more.

And while local tourism officials have long yearned –unsuccessfully so far –for a way to get those Niagara Falls tourists to stick around for more than three or four hours, we now know that Canadian shoppers take the same approach when they head to the local malls.

More than half of the Canadian shoppers who make day trips to the Buffalo Niagara region – and a third of those who stay overnight –don’t do anything else here but visit the mall, according to a study released last week by a Toronto-based tourism marketing research firm, Longwoods International.

“Right now, they know the track,” said Michael Erdman, Longwoods’ senior vice president and research director. “They know how to get to the Fashion Outlets. They know how to get to the Walden Galleria.”

But they don’t know how to get hardly any place beyond that, which kind of makes sense because they also don’t really know much about what else there is to do in the Buffalo Niagara region beyond driving to our malls and shopping.

That’s a costly mistake.

This is a perfect example of just how unsophisticated and thoughtless these leaders are.

John Percy, the president and chief executive officer of the Niagara Falls tourism bureau, said tourism officials need to come up with better brochures and other material that outline all the other things those shoppers can do here. And those materials need to be in places where it’s easy for Canadian shoppers to find them, namely the malls and shopper-oriented hotels.   Read the rest.

The problem is not the fact that local public funded agencies have seen their marketing revenues decline. The problem is there was never any marketing to begin with. This are is Balkanized, Politically and Economically incestuous, and accepting of the notion that there is no intrinsic value to this area for any potential visitor. And they are wrong.

Canadian shoppers and tourists is not a new invention. I remember them by the thousands in downtown Buffalo when I was a kid in the late 1950s. The Canadian has always been here and always taken for granted. Local businessmen where happy with what business they received due to currency fluctuations but were also too lazy to grow that business because they didn’t want to spend the money to attract more business and grow.

After traveling around for the past 9 months with associate Attorney  Jean Gittler meeting with and speaking to to anyone and everyone, I have found out you get an initial courtesy appointment and then you are dropped off the radar.  No one wants to be told they’ve been wrong and they must change. And they do. If you look at the core group of businessmen, civic leaders and politicians involved in growing the local economy you will see they have been around for decades and nothing has changed under them And yet, when you see groups being put together to find ways to grow the economy, the same people are interviewed, appointed and promoted as keys to success.

For this area to grow it needs thank these people, unload them, and bring in new blood willing do do the hard work necessary to attract shopper and tourist dollars rather than talk about it and be satisfied with what ever crumbs Canada’s exchange rate allows us.

The answer:   Advertisements and Promotions.

Advertise on Canadian Radio and TV

Advertise in Canadian newspapers.

Run contests offering  weekend shopping and entertainment packages.

NOT MAKE BETTER BROCHURES!!  If you want customers go get them, don’t expect them to come to you based on a brochure.  Let this non-tourism expert show our local businessmen and tourism insiders how to do it.

YouTube Preview Image

 

Lille OSC still has a chance to win the French Ligue 1 championship.

Lille, France like Dortmund, Germany is a Buffalo, NY Sister-City.  Like Dortmund last year Lille was league champion.  Unlike Dortmund, it has not secured the top spot.  There is an opportunity, but, it is a long-shot.  LOSC sits  in third place 5 points behind #2 Paris Saint-Germain and 7 points behind #1 Montpelier Herault FC with 5 matches (15 points available) remaining.

Good Luck Dogs – all is possible.

The Dogs and their Fans:

YouTube Preview Image

Borussia Dortmund still rocking the German Soccer (Football) World

Buffalo, NY’s “American Football” fans are hoping, once again, that good fortune is just around the corner for their Buffalo Bills.  The ever so faithful locals, the Bills have had only 18 winning seasons it their 52 year history, are on pins and needles that this year will be a break out year.

Across the pond, the Atlantic, Buffalo’s Sister-City of Dortmund has seen its’ beloved Borussia Dortmund squad capture a 2nd Bundesliga title in a row.  The Die Schwarzgelben (The Black Yellows) are now an annual threat to topple arch rival Bayern Munich ( I once saw them play in Cleveland against the U.S. National Team).  Congratulations to our German Brothers and Sisters.

They were nearly broke a few years ago, but now they’re (again) a serious competitor from league giants Bayern Munich. Borussia Dortmund are once again German champs and are established at the top of the league. It was a triumph of pure hunger that Borussia Dortmund managed to pull off once again. With two games to go before the end of the season, no one can take the title away from Dortmund; the defense of last year’s title came earlier than many soccer experts thought possible. With eight points to spare in front of second-place Bayern Munich, Dortmund secured their eighth German title in the team’s history, and won once again with a fresh and inspired approach to the game that has cemented them at the top of the league. Other than Dortmund’s 31-year-old goalkeeper, Roman Weidenfeller, and their 32-year-old captain, Sebastian Kehl, none of the regular players is over the age of 26 – and they’re still just as hungry for success as they were last year. Even without key players such as Nuri Sahin, who transferred to Real Madrid before the start of the season, or Mario Götze, who missed a large part of the season due to injury, the wins kept coming for Dortmund. The start of the season was a little rocky, and the unofficial fall championship eluded them, but in the end Dortmund’s nerves held. “This team is never satisfied and completely greedy,” said a proud Jürgen Klopp, the team’s coach, after their second derby victory over archrivals Schalke earlier this month. For the first time in 15 years, Dortmund also managed to get the best of Bayern Munich twice in the same season. “It’s unbelievable,” said the team’s chief executive Hans-Joachim Watzke. “This team squeezed every last bit of themselves out to the last drop.”  Read the Rest

Soccer Fever in Dortmund:

YouTube Preview Image